Casting : Aidan Gillen (as Jimmy Colby) Jessica Chastain (as ADA Sigrun Borg) Seth Gilliam (as ADA Terence Wright) Mary Fogarty (as Agatha Joynes) James Murtaugh (as Judge Addison Briggs) Ron Orbach (as Mike Railey) Scott Cohen (as Detective Chris Ravell) Lorraine Bracco (as Karla Grizano) Susan Blommaert (Judge Rebecca Steinman) Paul Lazar (Dave Baker) William Prael (Lyle Joynes) David Bishins (Tony Colby) Sarah Hyland (Brianne Colby) Brooke Elliott (Denise Bell) Sanjit De Silva (ADA Ed Kapoor) Katherine Puma (Nina Colby) Marco Verna (Roy Felder) Rob Leo Roy (Attorney Millard) Peter Van Wagner (Hearing Officer) Julia Barnett (Beth Jordan) Tom Zemon (Sam Crockett) Ray Wiederhold (Bailiff) Steve Zirnkilton (Opening Narration)