Casting : Mike Pniewski (as Stoller) Julia Gibson (as Selma Flanagan) Michael Hyatt (as defense attorney Julia Shinnear) Pippa Pearthree (Judge Esther Morrow) Matt Fischel (Judge Paul Fillmore) Susan Pellegrino (Officer Jeanette Donaldson) Matthew Stocke (Officer Jude Rhodes) M'el Dowd (Mrs. Haiduk) Richard Furlong (Det. Murphy) John Sierros (P.J. Grant) Stephen Park (Dr. Park) Jake M. Smith (Tommy Flanagan) Mason Pettit (Con Ed Guy) Dominic Inzana (Thruway Clerk) Jennifer Morris (Claire) Torben Brooks (Trooper) Robert Beitzel (Attendant) Rafeal Clements (Reporter #1) Kerrianne Spellman (Reporter #2) Eddie Martinez (Luis) Nicole Callender (Marisol) Patrick McCartney (Sgt. Leonetti) Michelle Rios (Woman) David Sajadi (Uni) Stracy Diaz (Sari) Mark Vincent Barlow (Paralegal) Paul Borghese (Clerk) Jacquie Ullendorf (Jury Foreperson)